Tag: ministry of education

  • Education Minister, Ministry, and Dodgy Dealings

    There are a lot of changes this government (National / ACT / NZFirst, 2023-2026) has made to the Education system in this country. The Education Minister along with the Ministry that serves them are largely responsible.

    I’m not going to lie. Some of the changes have been a case of ‘about time’. Some have been met with skepticism in the sector. And some, hilariously, were already being widely implemented throughout schools before the Government made them policy and took credit for the changes.

    Add it to the List

    However, there has been a great deal of controversy in how these changes have been pushed through. A fair bit of it slipped past the less observant public. There has been so much of it that teachers have become desensitised to it. My regular comment in the comment section is ‘Add it to the list’.

    But what list? I assume someone is keeping one, given how many instances of dodgy dealings have come to the surface. And where there’s smoke, there’s usually fire (unless you’re following behind a hipster with a vape).

    I’ve decided to write my own list, in case there is an absence of a list out there. Please feel free to share other findings that I may have missed or links to lists that others have already made.

    So far, there are 17 instances in this current government’s term of what I would call dodgy dealings.


    The List

    • Minister’s Personal Email Usage – May 2025
    • Stopping the de-colonisation – December 2023
    • MAG writes the Curriculum – March 2025
    • New Zealand Curriculum Re-Write – July 2025
    • NZQA Board salary increase – July 2025
    • Fergusson appointed as Chair of Teaching Council – July 2025
    • Teacher’s Institute funding – January 2026
    • Teacher’s Council takeover – June 2026
    • Fergusson now CEO of ERO – July 2026
    • Teaching Standards Expert Advisory Group – July 2026
    • Gold Coast coffee with Ben Jensen – June 2026
    • New Zealand Curriculum Tribunal Report – September 2026
    • Māori Words Removed – July 2026
    • Scribo procurement – February 2026
    • House of Science procurement – September 2026
    • Ministry of Education Toxic Workplace – September 2026
    • Ministry of Education OIA-able subversion – September 2026

    Minister’s Fwd Emails to Personal Accounts

    Education and Immigration Minister Erica Stanford sent pre-Budget announcements to her personal email prior to them being publicly announced last year, 1News can reveal.

    The revelation is just one of tens of examples of Stanford using her personal email for ministerial business over the course of her time as a minister.

    The emails, which were released following an Official Information Act (OIA) request, show Stanford putting her MP business signature on her personal email while communicating with her staff, school principals and various organisations.

    Erica Stanford sent pre-Budget documents to her personal email – 1 News


    Stopping the De-colonisation

    In April 2022, Dr Elizabeth Rata, a sociologist of education at the University of Auckland, published an online article examining what she described as the Ministry of Education’s attempts to “decolonise the New Zealand schooling system”.

    From there, Rata is then appointed by the Minister for the Ministers Advisory Group in which she has direct access to the curriculum re-write and can implement her mission to halt any ‘decolonisation’ within the curriculum.

    “A revolution is coming,” Rata wrote. “The government’s transformational policies for education make this clear. It will only be stopped by a re-commitment to academic knowledge for all New Zealand children, rich and poor alike, within a universal and secular education system.

    New education ministerial advisory group named – Inside Government

    ‘Idealogical’ school curriculum – Newsroom


    MAG writes the Curriculum

    An email to Rata from a Ministry of Education staffer implores: “Can you please not do anything further until the Minister has formally responded and we have everything set up for the writing teams”? Rata replies, “Oh dear, I wrote to 3 of the 7 members of the English Writing Team today to invite them to join.”

    The staffer reiterates: “I don’t want you to fall foul of government processes for establishing these sorts of groups, including procurement rules.” Johnston chips in: “I understand that it is the Ministry’s job to put together the writing groups, but they need to do so in consultation with key [ministerial advisory group] members. In the case of subject English, that means Elizabeth.”

    Removal of Māori knowledge, as well as, the overreach of Dr Elizabeth Rata and Dr Michael Johnson in their roles as advisors, into writing parts of the curriculum.

    Ideology is pushing Māori knowledge out of the curriculum – E-tangata


    New Zealand Curriculum Re-Write

    “Erica Stanford said the curriculum has been written by Kiwis for Kiwi kids and been benchmarked internationally against those from high-performing education systems around the world.” – Radio New Zealand

    Learning First writes the curriculum. Not advises on it. Writes it.

    “Several of the nine whistleblowers said the Australian firm Learning First had a major hand in draft curriculums and some ministry staff were flown to Melbourne to work with the company.

    One said the primary school maths curriculum was completely rewritten by Learning First and other learning areas were heavily influenced by the company.”

    “Another said Learning First wrote a lot of curriculum content, but ministry staff were told not to imply or say that the ministry was not the author of the curriculum.

    “Learning First replaced everything we had done,” they said.”

    Jensen said his company did not write the revised version of the maths curriculum

    “We provided comparisons with other systems and made suggestions,” he said. “We do a lot of work on how to sequence foundational learning in maths and what this means for the curriculum, but as above, we were not even doing this work when the draft was written.

    “A lot of the feedback we provided was rejected by the ministry, so the idea that we wrote most of it is simply not true.”

    AI is heavily involved, and numerous issues with the curriculum structure point to this (not least of all the writing of each and every year group, instead of in cohort ‘bands’ that most NZ schools are structured in – i.e. Year 3-4, Year 5-6, Year 7-8)

    Internal Education Ministry documents sighted by RNZ reveal serious problems plagued the rewrite of the school curriculum earlier this year and managers were considering using AI to help with the work.

    The latest leak from the organisation shows only a few months ago it lacked a clear definition of the core concept underpinning the entire rewrite – “knowledge rich” – even though it had already published primary school maths and English curriculums by that time and had nearly completed draft secondary school English and maths curriculums.

    It was also struggling with repeated requests for changes.

    Primary school principals and the secondary teachers union told RNZ they were worried about the curriculum development process.” – Stuff

    Later on in September, the Waitangi Tribunal releases it’s report on the new curriculum, and the Ombudsman gets involved due to issues at the Ministry of Education

    School curriculum rewrite – Radio New Zealand via Stuff

    Whistleblowers offer to aid Education Ministry probe – Radio New Zealand


    NZQA Board salary increase

    Cabinet ministers are defending a move to hike board fees for Crown bodies by up to 80 percent, insisting those in the roles are overseeing billions of dollars.

    Cabinet Ministers defend hiking board fees for Crown bodies – Radio New Zealand

    This includes the NZQA Board and Teacher’s Council Chair, both approved by the Minister.

    David Ferguson has been in the Minister’s ear securing funding for his Teacher’s Institute. He also sits on the NZQA Board.


    Teaching Council new Chair announced

    Announced by Minister of Education Hon Erica Stanford MP, this appointment recognises David’s commitment to educational excellence and leadership – from his work at the helm of The Teacher’s Institute, to his roles on the NZQA Board and the Ministry of Education’s NCEA Professional Advisory Group.

    David Ferguson is being appointed into top positions of key education roles by the Minister.

    CEO David Ferguson named Chair of Teaching Council – Teacher’s Institute


    Teacher’s Institute Funding

    The New Zealand Educational Institute (NZEI) and the Council of Deans of Education say messages obtained under the Official Information Act show a conflict of interest between the head of the Teaching Council, David Ferguson and Education Minister Erica Stanford.

    Most were texts sent in 2024 when Ferguson was principal of Westlake Boys’ High School but involved in setting up the Teachers’ Institute.

    The messages show Ferguson asked Stanford for advice and support about government funding for a teacher training institute he was helping set up before Stanford appointed him to the council.

    NZEI national secretary Stephanie Mills said the documents showed Ferguson received personal support from Stanford for successful bids for government funding for a private tertiary institute.

    “The Minister then appointed him as chair of the Teaching Council, which has responsibility for approving teacher training programmes. Together with her proposed legislative changes in the Education and Training (System Reform) Amendment Bill currently before Parliament, this raises significant questions about the Minister’s management of potential conflicts of interest and risks eroding trust in her judgement,” Mills said.

    Alleged conflict of interest messages between Teaching Council Chair and Education minister – Radio New Zealand


    Teacher’s Council takeover

    Minister makes sweeping changes to the Teaching Council

    Further changes to the Teaching Council include:

    • changing the threshold for removal of appointed Council members to be at the Minister’s discretion and introducing term limits for the chief executive.
    • strengthening the Teaching Council’s focus on protecting child safety, its quality assurance functions for initial teacher education and its reporting and monitoring arrangements
    • a requirement for the Council to give effect to government policy directions while also confirming the independence of its decision-making in individual cases
    • reducing the Council from 13 members to between 7 and 9 members, all appointed by the Minister – at least 3 members will have a minimum of 5 years’ education sector experience to provide sector knowledge and insight

    Education and Training Amendment Bill passed – Ministry of Education


    Ferguson now CEO of ERO

    David Ferguson was appointed by the Minister as Chair of the Teaching Council in 2025.
    Remember, Ferguson is also the CEO of Teacher’s Institute who contacted the Education Minister about Tertiary funding.
    The Minister then appoints Ferguson as Chair of the Teaching Council.

    Later on in June 2026, Ferguson is then appointed CEO of the Education Review Office (ERO), a role he accepts. At least he then resigns from Teacher’s Institute

    Chief Executive, Education Review Office appointed – Public Service
    Minister welcomes new ERO Chief Executive
    CEO David Fergusson announces departure – Teacher’s Institute


    Teaching Standards Expert Advisory Group

    The Expert Advisory Group (EAG) is comprised of recognised leaders in education, research, professional practice and public service. This expert advice helps to ensure teaching standards are informed by evidence, experience and diverse perspectives.

    Appointing no current classroom teachers to a newly formed Teaching Standards Expert Advisory Group (EAG) is a serious gap, NZEI Te Riu Roa says.

    “The voice of teachers at the chalkface has been a critical factor in developing teaching standards that are relevant, professionally sound, and owned by teachers themselves,” NZEI Te Riu Roa President Ripeka Lessels said.  

    One of the members on the advisory group is Dr. Nina Hood.

    Hood is co-founder of Teacher’s Institute along with David Fergusson.


    Gold Coast Coffee with Ben Jensen

    An Australian company paid over $2 million as part of Aotearoa’s education curriculum overhaul told Education Minister Erica Stanford it could help her “win hearts and minds” within schools.

    Stanford said her Gold Coast meeting with Jensen was “a catch up over coffee at an education conference and a range of education topics were discussed”.

    The ministry spent roughly $2.2 million with Learning First: just under $1.6m on services for the national curriculum refresh and a little over $600,000 for learning area resources.

    Ben Jensen is the CEO of Learning First, the company the Minister selected to advise on curriculum changes.

    Erica Stanford defends ‘coffee on Gold Coast’ – The Post

    Australian firm advises Stanford – Newsroom


    New Zealand Curriculum Tribunal Report

    The Tribunal found that the Crown, through its actions related to developing a ‘knowledge-rich curriculum’ informed by the ‘science of learning’, breached a number of Treaty principles.

    The Tribunal recommended that the Crown recommit to working in partnership with Māori in education and return to working with Māori on designing a truly indigenous Māori-medium and kaupapa Māori curriculum through Te Marautanga o Aotearoa. The Tribunal further provided the Crown with a list of features that it recommended should characterise the Crown’s renewed commitment to partnership. The Tribunal concluded that partnership was essential if the Crown were to correct its course and achieve equitable outcomes for ākonga Māori.

    The Waitangi Tribunal has found the actions of the Ministry and Minister in the re-written curriculum to be in breach of the Treaty of Waitangi principles.

    Tribunal releases report on the reform of the national curriculum – Waitangi Tribunal


    Māori Words Removed

    Official documents show Erica Stanford literally crossed out the words “ākonga Māori” and “Pacific students” from the new curriculum.

    The document shows notes from Minister Stanford’s own pen on the new curriculum, clearly asking for the removal of mentioning students of specific ethnicity. Let’s not forget that they are mentioned specifically because of long-standing struggles in educational achievement, and Māori akonga due to their status as tangata whenua.

    Most of the sources told RNZ they were told to remove Māori words from curriculum documents or noticed that others had done so.

    They said the word “Aotearoa” was used as a synonym for or alongside New Zealand in original curriculum drafts, but was later removed.

    “This instruction was never written down and, in some cases, senior staff made the changes themselves, rather than relay this change to the writing teams,” one source said.

    Another said Aotearoa New Zealand was the blanket term used in the curriculum, often shortened to ANZ, but proofreaders and editors were told to replace it with New Zealand.

    Māori words in curriculum – Radio New Zealand

    Government-flip-flopped on Treaty – Radio New Zealand


    Scribo – AI Writing Tool – Procurement

    The Education Minister is announcing new maths, English and science resources that were due to be in schools at the start of this year will now be rolled out.

    There will also be new science kits for primary school classrooms, an investment made in Budget 2025.

    The writing tool, called Scribo, is a teacher-facilitated 12-week tutoring programme providing targeted support for each student’s learning needs, she explained.

    There is more on the science kits for primary school classrooms later.

    However, what’s wrong with Scribo?

    Deb Masters was involved with EdConnect – the company rolling out Scribo – as late as May 2025. Deb Masters is now the Chief Strategic Adviser, Assessment and Aromatawai at Ministry of Education of New Zealand.
    This raises questions around how Scribo got the contract for the roll out of a Writing intervention for Year 6-8 (especially that it was then increased to Year 6-10).

    New maths, English, science resources – Radio New Zealand

    We need to talk about Scribo – I am Brie Elliot


    House of Science School Kit Procurement

    In February this year House of Science was confirmed as the supplier for the nationwide rollout of science and pūtaiao kits.

    But the contract is now facing fresh scrutiny after documents released under Official Information Act showed House of Science repeatedly lobbied Education Minister Erica Stanford for funding for their science kits before the contract was awarded and sought updates from her office during the tender process.

    Before the tender began House of Science chief executive Chris Duggan was also added to a group helping to write the science curriculum, on Stanford’s recommendation, despite the Ministry noting she had a significant financial conflict of interest and stood to gain materially from being on it.

    “She runs the House of Science – they provide science resources for schools – so she could directly benefit financially from being involved in this,” an official wrote.

    Yet another in a long list of dodgy dealings. Now in the science curriculum where those in the mix of writing the curriculum are now benefiting from decisions made, along with their lobbying directly with the Education Minister.

    Labour calls for investigation into $40m school science kit contract – Radio New Zealand


    Ministry of Education Toxic Workplace

    A damning review has found serious problems including allegations of favouritism and lack of public sector values in the Education Ministry’s curriculum division.

    The division is responsible for the government’s curriculum rewrite and has been under scrutiny this week after multiple whistleblowers alleged attempts to subvert the Official Information Act.

    It found widespread concern about favouritism by senior leaders, especially in relation to the many temporary appointments in Te Poutāhū | Curriculum Centre. It found widespread concern regarding the application of public sector values and principles including fair and transparent appointment processes, conflict of interest management and concerns about the obligation to give free and frank advice to the minister not being met.

    Many participants said the curriculum centre’s leadership was outdated and authoritarian, the report stated.

    Examples included unreasonable and intimidating behaviours, a general prevalence of swearing – though not at people, and rudeness.

    Some participants said they had seen bullying, others said they had not but gave examples of less-than-ideal leadership practices.

    The Ombudsman launches an investigation into the Ministry at the end of September. This was in relation to the subversion of OIA loophole recorded on video from a senior manager.

    We need to remember; the Ministry of Education does not serve schools. It serves one person; the Education Minister.

    Allegations of favouritism, ‘unsustainable’ workloads at Education Ministry’s curriculum division – Radio New Zealand

    Whistleblowers offer to aid Education Ministry probe – Radio New Zealand


    Ministry of Education OIA-able subversion

    The secondary teachers union fears a video that shows an education official seemingly trying to “subvert” the Official Information Act is part of a wider problem with secrecy around the government’s curriculum rewrite.

    The head of the Education Ministry is investigating the case after leaked footage given to the NZ Herald showed senior Ministry of Education official Catherine Law telling staff not to put information shared with the minister’s office in writing and reminding them it was “OIA-able” – referencing the Official Information Act.

    The head of the Education Ministry is no longer investigating the case seeing as the Office of the Ombudsman was conducting their own investigation.

    “It confirms rumours we’ve been hearing that there’s this real push to not have things written down, to be really opaque about what’s occurring in the curriculum,” he (Chris Abercrombie, PPTA President) said.

    “I don’t think this one individual just decided off their own bat that this was something they were going to talk about. I think this is really clearly a government trying to work in secret on the curriculum and you tie this in with the heavy use of non-disclosure agreements, the significant sort of pushing out of individual voices – this is a real concern.”

    How does this impact on the Minister?

    “The Minister of Education stands to benefit from this attempt by ministry staff and her office to breach transparency because it reduces public scrutiny of her decision-making,” Mills said.

    “It is implausible in our view that she had no knowledge of the approach they were taking.”

    A former Education Ministry curriculum writer, Claire Coleman, said the video was the type of behaviour she and other ministry staff had encountered.

    “It’s not a surprise to me in the slightest,” she said.

    The Ministry, who serve the Education Minister, are actively advising staff to only converse verbally, and to refrain from putting anything down in writing so that it cannot be included in any Official Information Act request. While this kind of subversion must have been going on for years, in various different departments, the fact is that it was caught on camera as clear as day as being a directive from senior managers.

    Senior official appearing to try hide information being taken ‘very seriously’ – Radio New Zealand


    Why?

    Why write all this?

    In researching this, I have used a few different sources, but all of them directly from the organisations themselves, or reputable news sources such as Radio New Zealand.

    While I was researching, I did come to notice some familiar timings and dates of when a lot of these news articles broke. Some came about as things happened, but I am not so naive to think that some haven’t been released as political propaganda to discredit the current government.

    My position is this: It wouldn’t matter if these dodgy dealings were being done by any Education Minister; it’s the fact that these are happening all the time with the current Minister, and within the Ministry. Although they get mentioned in the mainstream media, no one is holding them to account for their actions in procurement or appointments being made. Week after week it seems that there is another funding faux pas where someone who has a conflict of interest is directly or indirectly involved with the Minister and normal tenders of procurement are simply ignored and large sums of money being funneled straight to mates in the sector. There seem to be a handful of people being put into positions of power over key aspects of the Education system in this country. The secrecy and

  • Deathstar

    After another Ministry of Education hui for principals, a comment was made that the whole fiasco of the Community of Schools / Community of Learning negotiations with NZEI, have left teachers “…with the Deathstar, but we get to choose what colour lasers they use!”. I found it quite comical, and certainly falls inline with my views on the IES which can be found here.

  • Community of Learning Mincer

    In relation to Ministry comments at a recent Community of Learning hui for Board of Trustees.

    “The Community of Learning… is a pathway… to move a student through the pipeline…”

  • Rangiora High principal ‘bullied’


    Rangiora High School’s principal alleges ”sustained bullying” by the school’s commissioner.

    Source: Rangiora High principal ‘bullied’

    This follows on from this ongoing saga for this school and this principal that has been happening since the start of last year.

    Finally someone in the media has hooked onto this. Quite ready for John Campbell to get back in the NZ Media spotlight! He would have been all over this!

    It seems like a very bad situation to be in, one that could only be seen in a movie.

    But it’s not. It’s real. And it is happening now.

    Kelvin Smythe has been a long time education reporter and writer, and has picked up on this issue since it happened.

    In cold blood: terror as an instrument of control in state education Part 1

    In cold blood: the Rangiora Horror Show Part 2

    Both of these articles are reasonably lengthy, but given the multitude of steps taken in this saga, it isn’t any wonder! I implore you to read them, and then form your opinion on whether you agree with what has happened. Obviously, Kelvin has his angle on any of these issues, but also gets his information from a variety of sources. However anti-government he appears to be, I do believe his intent is always to write the truth.

    And if this is anything to go by, its a terrifying series of events.

    It sucks to have to make my first posting of 2016 about something so horrific.

    Happy New Year everyone.

     

  • Do as I say, not do as I do – Consulting the Community

    A rising trend is occurring right before our eyes, and it’s  more than concerning. It’s definitely poor role-modelling, and is more than just a little unfair.

    For years the Education Review Office has been wandering around the country critiquing schools on their community engagement and consultation in an effort to get schools to get parents interested in their child’s education; supposedly to address the supposed “long tail” of underachievement that has hindered our nation for the last countless decades. Schools have then gone above and beyond to engage whanau, caregivers, kindergartens, churches, and more, in an effort to get the ERO off their backs… Oh, and try and address any under-achievement.

    The reality is, that schools have worked incredibly hard on this and have invested their time heavily, and the same problem remains; the difficult parents are still hard to get a hold of, and the ones who already support their child and value education are only too happy to support the school.

    So while the ERO and the Ministry would have teachers invest heavily in consulting the community, the same does not happen from the Minister at all.

    Consultation

    This has been highlighted on numerous occasions at the lack of consultation within the education sector during the reign of Ms. Parata (and her predecessor, Ms. Tolley). One shouldn’t have to remind people of the introduction of National Standards. In recent times; there has been the Novopay botch up, the reneg on class sizes, the closure of some Christchurch schools (1,2,3), and the announcement of IES, all of which had little or no consultation with schools.

    Even when the Minister does decide to consult the sector, it is done in less than ideal ways. Take the latest consultation around the Education Act. The changes were announced six weeks before the deadline; and while this is seemingly enough time, one cannot ignore the irony that the consultation has been conducted at the busiest time of year for teachers, principals, and schools alike, and this is even before we find out if submissions that do make it through are heard and listened to. Add to this, that the closing of Parliament in upcoming weeks for the Christmas break, for this Education Act to be passed through in the new year. Why would you not allow submissions to be made over Christmas and January, when teachers would be able to voice their concerns or ideas? Well – simply because they don’t want to hear from their community.

    Community

    As of this year, the Minister now hand picks who is on the Education Council; the overseeing body of teacher conduct and registration. There is no longer any member on the council that is elected by teachers. This is hardly democratic, and is indicative of things to come, such as Ministry appointed school boards. In a sense, there is no one who represents the community on the community board.


    In the announced changes to the Education Act, it is quite clear that the Minister wants to centralise a lot of different parts of the school community. Boards of Trustees will eventually be phased out in favour of a Board that runs several schools. This will be in conjunction with the introduction of “Communities of Learning” and the selection (somehow) of lead principals. I’m not sure how a selection of principals when put in a room would decide who will be the lead principal and get a nice sum as a bonus. No doubt, eventually, the Ministry will have to select or appoint a principal to be the lead principal.
    As each school becomes part of a bigger community, the community will grow. But that’s not always a good thing. As a community gets bigger, it becomes more difficult to organise that community, or even get a sense of community. Imagine, if you will, a board in charge of your school with parents you never see, and don’t recognise because they don’t have children at your school and don’t even live in the same area. The same thing will happen with lead principals, as they get tied up with more leadership in other schools, there is the high possibility they’ll never be seen in their own schools. Students already have a hard enough job seeing their principal as it is, let alone if they’re going to be running other schools as well.

    In conclusion

    So while the ERO and the Ministry would have schools consult their community to address issues within schools, the Minster is busy removing the sense of community within the education sector, and also to make it impossible to have a community to engage with once they’re finished. If a community is too large, it no longer keeps its sense of community, and becomes untenable to organise and maintain. Eventually, the “top-down” model imposes its ideas on everyone else and they are told to put up or shut up. As for consultation, it would be safe to assume that the Minister has only recently found the definition of it in her dictionary. Up until now, it hasn’t even been a consideration. We are still waiting to see what is done with whatever number of submissions the Minister receives, but if past experience is anything to go by, there is a rather large rug being lifted up to sweep them under.

  • Listen to Reading

    One thing I have always been an advocate for is reading to the students. Most days I will set aside 10-15 minutes for this, if not more. With this ‘Listening Post’ so to speak, however, students have texts read to them aloud whenever they want.

    Listening Post with my class has been the introduction of headphones and Ministry provided MP3’s on our web server for students to access. With this, I have gathered the selection of Ready to Read texts along with them, and have created boxes in my classes for these books to sit in.

    Students choose the book, then look up the MP3 on the web server, and push play. Easy as that.

    Listening to reading is supported by various readings around different literacy sites. ‘The power of reading and listening‘ by Warren Ediger says “Scientific research tells that most of our fluency – our ability to use a language – comes from what we read and hear.” In addition to this, ‘Learning through listening‘ states “Supported reading is reading with the support of recorded materials. Individuals read along with the novels or textbooks while they listen to the verbatim recording of the same material. When students are engaged in supported reading, they no longer have to labor over every word. Instead, they can read at a comfortable pace that allows them to acquire the information contained in the text.”, which I think sums up my feelings on the assistance that being able to listen to the text brings for these students.

    What I have noticed is that all students engage with this more than they would with just a book on its own. It works regardless of ability, and struggling readers are not only reading with their eyes, but hearing the words decoded for them and the language is being learned on multiple levels.